Plot twist 2: Two of the three have penises. Choose carefully.

If you ask the younger one out, with whom you've had less interaction, you are more likely to be rejected - you would also be rejected by the original girl out of anger for going after her younger sister.

Ask the original girl out. Forget about the sister.

EDIT: "Your sister is gorgeous... were you adopted?"

> _

Here's how you know this will end in failure.

Corn put a emoticon of one-eye will. So now we know for sure the tail is wagging the dog.

It was meant to be a prompt, similar to a MUD game prompt, asking the user for an action...

Hey I don't mean to sound like a jerk but basing your decision purely on looks seems a little...shallow - I know we're all hardwired to respond to physical beauty but maybe just hang out with the both of them and see who you click with? Then again I am basically your stereotypical awkward guy so my relationship advice is dubious at best.

I completely agree with this. This is not 1000 B.C. Try to see which one of the two is smarter (if you yourself are smart).

Depends on what you mean by "ridiculously pretty", I tend to avoid approaching close to perfect looks or what is considered 'perfect', you can blame hot actors for this, everyone more or less looks the same and somehow 'hot' became the new 'not'. Don't get me wrong image is very important (as is personality) and I approach people mostly because of that, but looking at someone almost perfect would turn me on or interest me as much as doing the dishes would

Go with the not so perfect looks one.

I have no idea why I'm responding to this thread, but I just wanted to point out - choosing someone because they are smart is just as shallow and judgemental as choosing them because they are attractive.

It was meant to be a prompt, similar to a MUD game prompt, asking the user for an action...

Plot twist: You then meet their mother, who is somehow even better looking than both sisters, complete knockout and has both maturity and experience on her side. What do you do now?

Lesson learned: Check the girl's FB profile and look for hot sisters/girlfriends first.

(plus if she's that gorgeous: There will be some competition between you computer geek and some Olympic champion academics. And/or she's already doing porn)

> talk to the older sister

Here the advice of the sages: Stay with whomever you first interested in. The moment you switch, they both would know, and both would ditch you in an instant.