I'd definitely be down with sharing all of our compositions and any feedback from the judges!

Quote:

Original post by nsmadsen I'm fine with the idea but I want to check first with everyone who participated since some may not want their work or their scores made public.

Fair point. I guess you can make it an opt-in, only post a small selection, or anonymize all entries outside the top three or something. Whatever works for you guys. I'd just love to listen to the samples and read the feedback of the judges. :)

Quote:

Original post by Wan Good stuff! Nice to see so many participated. Perhaps it's a bit much to ask, but will there be a overview of all the submissions together with links to the audio files, all the scores, relevant comments of the judges etc, like the four element contests? Sound and music isn't exactly my field of expertise, so I would love to read the opinions of people who actually know what they are talking about. Again, kudos to all the organizers and participants! [smile]

I think this is great idea!

I wouldn't mind if my composition and it's relevant feedback was posted. You have my permission and support for this idea!

Andy.W

Quote:

Original post by Wan Quote: Original post by nsmadsen I'm fine with the idea but I want to check first with everyone who participated since some may not want their work or their scores made public. Fair point. I guess you can make it an opt-in, only post a small selection, or anonymize all entries outside the top three or something. Whatever works for you guys. I'd just love to listen to the samples and read the feedback of the judges. :)

Yeah, it's pretty cool.. And I also think it should not be private, it should be seen by all the people if contestants wouldn't mind much that their tracks are shared...

Anyway, I know what comments to expect for my tracks.. I feel that my entry is prety weak and everyone will be like "bla bla bla not scary.. blalala overlaping too much blabla".. :D

Quote:

Perhaps it's a bit much to ask, but will there be a overview of all the submissions together with links to the audio files, all the scores, relevant comments of the judges etc, like the four element contests?

+1

Quote:

Original post by Wan Good stuff! Nice to see so many participated. Perhaps it's a bit much to ask, but will there be a overview of all the submissions together with links to the audio files, all the scores, relevant comments of the judges etc, like the four element contests? Sound and music isn't exactly my field of expertise, so I would love to read the opinions of people who actually know what they are talking about. Again, kudos to all the organizers and participants! [smile]

I'm OK with it and I would be glad to hear others scores.

Nathan, I was just wondering if this contest is annual or a one time deal. If it is suppose to be annual will it be every month year or what?

Quote:

Original post by reaper567 Nathan, I was just wondering if this contest is annual or a one time deal. If it is suppose to be annual will it be every month year or what?

It's annual. Perhaps if the contest got a huge amount of interest then we could move it to every 6 months but it also takes a good amount of time to coordinate and such. It is fun though! It's my hope that each time year this contest gets bigger and better! (Yes, that includes the prizes as well! :P )

Thanks,

Nate

I'm ok with posting the reviews and song files here and a contest every 6 months would be great indeed