Hi there,

I am also ok with posting my composition and having the possibility to read the feedback from the judges.

Greetings
AJ

Hey Everyone,

I think it would be great to hear the spectrum of approaches to this challenge and I think we should encourage sharing. I feel, though, that the judges' feedback should be between them and the respective contestant (if they are indeed providing individualized feedback). Perhaps the winning three could have a line or two from the judges that demonstrates what they felt about those tracks that put them over the top.

Thanks,

George

I was considering the same thing. The judges have the option to provide private or public feedback which then I could share accordingly. The last thing I want to do is embarrass someone or hurt someone's feeling publicly so I'm going to do what I can to make this a positive, learning experience when getting feedback.

Agreed, Nathan. Perhaps the judges could talk in a more general way. For instance, they could describe what criteria they each used for crtiquing (e.g. compositional merit, context, creativity, audio engineering, etc). This way, we know from their point of view what merits a strong track. It could ultimately avoid pointed criticism and isolating individuals.

Feedback, public or private, is good with me.

I think it would be cool to hear all the entries, just to hear the different takes and ideas on the same material.

Fine with me too. Personally I'd like to hear the competition.

Good idea.


Nate still waiting on that pm

Quote: Agreed, Nathan. Perhaps the judges could talk in a more general way. For instance, they could describe what criteria they each used for crtiquing (e.g. compositional merit, context, creativity, audio engineering, etc). This way, we know from their point of view what merits a strong track. It could ultimately avoid pointed criticism and isolating individuals.

Very good point.

Consider this my approval to post tunes and feedback.

Looking forward to the results!!

Thanks

DM

Any news? ;)