News stories are interesting things.
Normally headlines are designed to grab your attention and get you to read the story. In these days of analytics and view-based revenue, they'll say whatever they can to get you to click the link.
A common example that has been suggested for decades is to think about news articles written about your own field. News reporters are not in that field, unless the news report happens to be about the news media itself.
Whatever the field an individual is in, when they see a news story about their chosen industry most people can realize that the news stories had problems, missed details, or even completely missed the point. Yet when discussing something not in their field, most people consider news stories as true.
Also remember the nature of news is not to publish the commonplace and everyday events. If something is commonplace it is NOT reported.
Is there some Islamaphobia? Yes, some. Is it running rampant? No, most people are level headed. There are always idiots out there doing stupid things, but they are the exception to the rule which makes them newsworthy.