It's a game that screenshots do not do justice to.
It's distinctive and memorable and definitely more...
I think my case with Undertale was actually a prime example of "Judging by the cover" instead :(.
For the op: sry, for misinforming.
I'm making a game and visually it looks like... junk.
We should try it first, at least share some footage, maybe you are underestimating its appeal.