Hello Should I Python or Perl? or should I stick with Java and Bash script? As 1) Business/web aplication programmer 2) System administrator 3) Network programmer

debaere

122

January 30, 2005 12:35 PM

There is no right answer, but I would say use the tools that works best for you in the current situation your in. It all depends on exactly what you are trying to accomplish, and your comfort level using the languages.

For myself, the following is true:

For automatic things like startup scripts, BASH is the way to go.

For system administration scripts I prefer Perl. I find that Perls libraries more closely match the under lying Unix commands and conceptually its easier.

I use Python for coding apps, and PHP for web.

I would think that Java would be tougher to use for system administration programs, but I don't have much experience outside of school with Java so I cannot be certain.

eedok

982

January 30, 2005 10:06 PM

ESR says use python

but then again everyone knows that VB is the bestest way to go :P. But seriously that article speaks loudly on the differences between py and pl.

AMP Minibowling - Free asynchronous multiplayer mobile minigolf+bowling
[twitter]eedok[/twitter]

C-Junkie

1,099

January 30, 2005 10:16 PM

In a linux environment (probably including the BSDs), python shines. For other unices, perl might be better.

grazer

114

January 30, 2005 11:48 PM

They are not mutually exclusive. Learn them both. Python has a clean object syntax, and Perl has the CPAN.

tentoid

364

January 31, 2005 03:51 PM

I really like Python but I haven't used Perl. I must say that python is ridiculously easy and fast language to use. I am constantly amazed by it's power and it's vast module library. But as they say, use the right tool for the right job..

Personally, I would use python as a system admin and a network programmer. Not sure about web application programmer since I've always used PHP on web side of things (although some python fans say that python is better in that area than PHP).

(I hope you can decipher this message.. I am a bit too tired.)

Ad: Ancamnia

cwhite

586

January 31, 2005 11:55 PM

This is a religious war, and as a member of the church of py, i have to say perl users are sinners and need to repent now.

Seriously, though, it's all about preference.

turnpast

1,011

February 02, 2005 06:32 PM

This sort of question is fairly common and rarely does anything but start a flame war. If you want more than opinion the only answer is research and experience.

The GameDev forums, in my experience, are a bad place to research language decisions.

eedok

982

February 03, 2005 01:06 PM

I'm sorry but I find that link really funny, looking at the perl pages:
# Is Perl Difficult? - Author Paul Presocd says Perl is hard to learn, and suggests Python as a useful alternative.
# Why We Hate Perl - Multiple opinions, most of which are negative, of the language.

then the python pages:
# Python: Yes, You Should Be Using It! - Alex Martelli gives an overview of the possibilities offered by Python, along with samples allowing the newcomer to experience Python code. (April 1, 2002)
# Why Python? - Patrick O'Brien's Python advocacy page.

AMP Minibowling - Free asynchronous multiplayer mobile minigolf+bowling
[twitter]eedok[/twitter]