I see a lot of posts around here (some of them my own) that request feedback on self-made music tracks. But there seems to be more people wanting feedback than those willing to give it. So I thought, maybe we should establish a dedicated group where each member can submit a number of tracks per month and get feedback on specific points from other group members. In return, you'd have to do some critiquing yourself. This could work as a sticky thread in this forum where group members would hang out, or it could be a mailing list where people mailed the group members with links. Alternately, does anyone know of any active communities where you can go to in order to get critique? - sort of like a conceptart.org for musicians.

I'm down for that.

That's a cool idea. I think there would be a lot of artists who will join that (looking at art-sites like deviantArt). I wish you good luck.

Register the domain. Get hosting. Design a site. Build a community.

I think it's a great idea and would like to help.

Well, my original plan was something along the lines of a mailing list where members could post links to their music, but if anyone can set up a message board for this purpose, cool.

I was thinking something along the lines of each member getting to post maybe 2 tracks per month for critique, or something. (Too many tracks per month x A lot of members = An insurmountable number of tracks to critique for everyone.)

What about a yahoo group?

Quote: Original post by NCSURedstorm
What about a yahoo group?

That's a no-no.

And why?

If you have to ask, you don't need to know. :)